Bummer, the RealHer Lipliner, Elegant Charm, that I got in my September 2025 BoxyCharm/Ipsy box has been discontinued. This is disturbing for three reasons: I really like this dual-ended lipliner, but it’s listed on the RealHer website as “sold out”. However, it seems to be discontinued and replaced by a different lipliner, Retractable Lip …

